Friday, February 23, 2007

Cell Phones in Schools

I know there are more and more people with cell phones everyday. Many people depend on them for business and communication with family members. With the current wireless providers continuing to expand, there are few places left where cell phones can not be used. One place where I feel they should not be used is in schools.

Sometimes when I'm out shopping I see young girls and boys with cell phones, who are barely old enough to be out of elementary school. Because of the rising number of students (in all grades) with cell phones, this is an important issue to consider.
Some people may give excuses as to why they should be allowed. Some include parents being able to reach their children in a time of emergency, or the students contacting the parents. To this I say, "That's what the school is for." The principal's and dean's offices are there for students and parents when one or the other needs to be contacted in an emergency. Although a cell phone could be faster, it is also a distruption in class. If we were to allow cell phones for emergencies, students would then be allow to call them all the time (because who can predict when an emergency situation will occur?). This then presents a distraction to students and to teachers. Cell phones can be used to play games during class or to cheat on homework and tests.

Some people fear that cell phones make it easier for gang members to collaborate during the school day. Although I do not see this as the biggest issue, it is also another point to consider.
There are one or two exception that I would allow in my classroom/school. If there is a family trauma (i.e. an expected death in the family, an on-going helth concern, etc.), a cell phone may be allowed. This is something that would have to be discussed with the principal, tecahers, parents, and students to find an agreement that works.

So, turn them off, and leave them in your locker/purse/briefcase, or leave them at home.

1 comment:

Associate Professor of Education, Luther College said...

I agree. Keep the cell phones at home. It seems to me the problems they create outweigh the benefits. Thanks for a nice start to this blog.

Dr. Langholz